Notes

The 1928 National Examination (第一屆國術國考) — the Guoshu movement's great test

Updated 2026-06-05

On this page

In October 1928, the new Central Guoshu Institute staged the 第一屆國術國考 (First National Martial Arts Examination) in Nanjing — an attempt to put the whole sprawling, secretive world of Chinese boxing on a public stage and test it, head to head, in the ring. It became the most famous martial event of the Republican era, and one of its messiest. The story the tradition tells about it is heroic; the story the records tell is more human, and more interesting.

The setting

The Central Guoshu Institute (中央國術館) had been founded only that March, a state-backed effort to nationalize, standardize and modernize the martial arts as 國術 (guóshù, "national art"). Its director was the general 張之江 (Zhang Zhijiang); its deputy was the "Sword Saint" Li Jinglin. The examination was the Institute's first great public undertaking, held not in its own halls but at the 南京公共體育場 (Nanjing Public Sports Ground) over nine days in October 1928. (Sources place the dates across roughly 11–19 October; accounts differ by a few days.) The patron 馮玉祥 (Feng Yuxiang) supplied the prizes, and the opening is reported to have drawn speeches from Feng, Zhang Zhijiang, and Chiang Kai-shek himself.

How it was meant to work

The examination ran in two phases:

預試 (preliminary) — a demonstration of solo forms (套路), to qualify.
正試 (formal) — two-person full-contact bouts on a leitai platform, pairings drawn by lot, decided best of three (三戰兩勝).

The combat was divided into four "gates": 拳腳門 (bare-hand striking), 摔角門 (wrestling), 刀劍門 (short weapons), and 棍槍門 (long weapons) — the four gates of technique put to the test.

What actually happened

The full-contact phase went badly. With minimal protection and real strikes, the 正試 turned bloody — Chinese accounts say plainly that the examination "出現了流血場面" (produced bloody scenes) and was, on the whole, poorly run. After about three days the field had narrowed to a small circle of survivors, and the organizers made a fateful call: they stopped the fighting and settled the final ranking by a judges' / evaluative decision rather than letting the last bouts run to a finish.

Three reasons are given, and all three are probably true at once: the goal was to select the strongest men to staff the Institute, so a clean win-loss ladder was unnecessary and even unhelpful (不分勝敗名次，便於共事 — "no ranking by victory, easier to work together"); the schedule and budget had run out; and there was real fear of deaths if the remaining elites kept "trading killing techniques" (互施絕技，恐出傷亡事故).

There was even a prize problem: Feng Yuxiang had prepared exactly fifteen awards, but the finalists numbered more — so two men were persuaded to accept being joint head of the standings (榜首), each given a Longquan sword, in place of the formal top rank and its prize.

The results — and the legend they fed

First place went to 朱國福 (Zhu Guofu) — and all three Zhu brothers (朱國福, 朱國祿, 朱國楨), students of the great synthesizer Sun Lutang, reached the top tier (最優等). Zhu Guofu was famous for folding Western boxing into his Xingyi, and the Institute hired him the next year. The top cohort of fifteen ran heavily to Hebei Xingyi and Bagua men, alongside figures like 顧汝章 (Gu Ruzhang) of Northern Shaolin, 王雲鵬, 張長義, 馬裕甫, and 竇來庚.

The sequel: the 1933 examination

The Second National Examination (第二屆國術國考), held in Nanjing 20–30 October 1933 at the same ground, was visibly modernized by the lessons of 1928: Western-style weight classes, designated referees and judges, explicit sportsmanship rules, and kendo-like protective armor in both empty-hand and weapons bouts. The combat was now sorted into five categories — striking, wrestling (摔跤), short weapons, long weapons, and free-fighting (搏擊). The grim notice often quoted from this milieu — that a competitor's coffin would be sent home should he die — is widely repeated, and best reported as said to have been posted rather than quoted as official text.